Credit: Google
Since its introduction to the Premier League in the 2019-20 season, the Video Assistant Referee (VAR) system has been a polarizing addition to football, claimed to be designed to correct clear and obvious errors in decisions involving goals, penalties, red cards, and mistaken identities. However, the system has reportedly faced persistent criticism for lengthy reviews, inconsistent application, and its impact on the spontaneity of matches. On the other hand, many reports say that some believe the VAR system should be expanded to help improve the accuracy of decisions, as calls on free-kicks and corners are currently made by on-field officials.
Reportedly, Football Association (FA) chief executive Mark Bullingham has firmly dismissed calls to expand the use of the Video Assistant Referee (VAR) system in English football, arguing that the current model already introduces “enough interruptions” to the game. In his statement Bullingham further said, “We don’t think there’s any need to extend the use of VAR.” There have been reports that the International FA Board which governs football’s laws, could be asked to consider widening VAR powers to include corner kicks and second yellow cards. However, the FA, which has a place in the body alongside the three other British associations and FIFA, has made its opposition clear.
VAR has been in the centre of conflicts for many reported controversial decisions
In 2023, FIFA referees chief Pierluigi Collina reportedly said that widening the use of VAR would be considered, but insisted it must not mean more delays. During Euro 2024, England’s semi-final loss to the Netherlands was marred by a debated penalty decision, reportedly prompting manager Gareth Southgate to call for “better communication” from officials. In the Premier League, the 2024-25 season saw 20% of matches feature VAR interventions, with an average review time of 68 seconds, according to ESPN.
While the system overturned 112 incorrect decisions last season, fan frustration has grown over delays and perceived subjectivity, with a YouGov poll cited by The Telegraph showing 54% of supporters favor scrapping VAR entirely. The FA’s position follows a challenging period for VAR, with high-profile controversies shaping public and professional sentiment. For the time being, FA has made it clear that any vote would take place at the body's annual general meeting in March, set to be held in Cardiff. Each of the British associations has one vote on motions, while Fifa has four. Passing a rule change requires a three-quarters majority of the board to agree.
